← CABF Ballot Browser
Ballot-121 failed

Ballot 121 – EV Guidelines Insurance Requirements(failed)

Server Certificate Working Group

Key dates

Voting opened
30 Apr 2014 12 years ago
Voting closed
07 May 2014 12 years ago
Discussion opened
23 Apr 2014 12 years ago
Discussion closed
30 Apr 2014 12 years ago

AI Summary

Generated 2026-06-23 21:35 UTC

Ballot overview

  • Ballot 121 proposed changes to EV Guidelines Section 8.4 on insurance requirements.
  • The motion would have required each CA to maintain commercial general liability insurance and professional liability/errors and omissions insurance, with specified minimum coverage amounts and insurer rating requirements.
  • The motion also allowed self-insurance if a CA had at least 500 million US dollars in liquid assets, audited financial statements from the past twelve months, and a quick ratio of at least 1.0.
  • The ballot text argues that the existing insurance requirements were not effective, were North America-centric, could be expensive for smaller CAs, and did not meaningfully protect relying parties or customers.

Ballot status

  • Voting closed on Ballot 121.
  • The page states that Ballot 121 failed.
  • The evidence gives the review period and voting period dates, but the ballot did not become normative because it failed.

Dates stated in the evidence

  • Review period: 2014-04-23 2200 UTC to 2014-04-30 2200 UTC.
  • Voting period: 2014-04-30 2200 UTC to 2014-05-07 2200 UTC.
Model: gpt-5.4-mini Confidence: 0.99 Result: failed
Voting opened
2014-04-30
Voting closed
2014-05-07
Discussion opened
2014-04-23
Discussion closed
2014-04-30

AI-generated from the CABF ballot page. The official CABF article remains the authoritative source.

Excerpt

SearchHome » All CA/Browser Forum Posts » Ballot 121 – EV Guidelines Insurance Requirements(failed)Ballot 121 – EV Guidelines Insurance Requirements(failed)Ballot 121 – EV Guidelines Insurance Requirements Voting has closed on Ballot 121. “Yes” votes were cast by Buypass, Disig, Firmaprofesional, GlobalSign, GoDaddy, Izenpe, OpenTrust, SSC, Trend Micro, Turktrust, and WoSign. “No” votes were cast by Actalis, DigiCert, QuoVadis, Symantec, and Mozilla. Abstentions were submitted by StartCom, Visa, and Google. Therefore, Ballot 121 failed.

View on cabforum.org → Last fetched 16 hours ago

We use only essential cookies and local browser storage for preferences and security. See our Privacy Policy for details.

Confirm action